🔥
IdeaRoast Analysis
a platform to roast ideas like sharks in shark tank.. user inputs ideas and gets roasted.. "... so I'm out" but I'd be interested if you do this.. as I like this kinda..
The Roast
"You've basically invented a content machine that monetizes schadenfreude—which is hilarious until you realize most people want *feedback*, not entertainment roasting. You're one YouTube series away from irrelevance, and you'd need a *really* compelling angle to compete with actual Shark Tank clips."
Reality Check
Market Saturation
8/10
Skill Match
6/10
Time Realism
5/10
Revenue Potential
3/10
đź’€ Why This Fails
- • Entertainment-only businesses are brutally hard to monetize (YouTube ad rates are terrible, viral isn't repeatable)
- • Free user-generated content is commodified—Reddit roasts ideas for free already
- • No real value prop: users get laughed at, not actual actionable feedback they'd pay for
âś… The Pivot
Become 'Brutal Feedback as a Service' for founders/solopreneurs: Charge $99-299/month for structured monthly roast sessions with *real* strategic pivots, market analysis, and competitive positioning. You're not entertainers—you're paid consultants who happen to be funny. Position as 'Shark Tank coaching' for pre-seed founders who can't afford $5K/hour VC consultants.
Current Idea
3/10 — Viral-bait with no moat or monetization
Pivoted Idea
8/10 — Niche B2B service with clear WTP and defensible positioning
Share this roast