🔥
IdeaRoast Analysis
Q:Creator Identity Builder
“What’s my niche + voice + aesthetic?”
The Roast
"You've just described every $47 Notion template and LinkedIn guru's entire business model—except you haven't specified what makes yours different or why creators should pay you instead of asking ChatGPT for 30 seconds. This is the side hustle equivalent of selling 'business advice': everyone thinks they have it, nobody wants to buy it."
Reality Check
Market Saturation
9/10
Skill Match
6/10
Time Realism
5/10
Revenue Potential
3/10
💀 Why This Fails
- • Vague value prop—'identity builder' could mean literally anything and competes with free AI tools
- • Low barrier to entry = infinite competitors offering similar vibes-based coaching
- • Hard to charge meaningfully; creators want results (followers, sales), not aesthetic validation
✅ The Pivot
Instead: Pick ONE creator vertical (e.g., 'Personal finance TikTok creators') + offer a specific, measurable service (e.g., 'Audit your hook-to-CTA flow and A/B test 3 variants'). Charge based on results. You're now a performance consultant, not a life coach.
Current Idea
3/10 — Oversaturated Vibes Consultant
Pivoted Idea
6.5/10 — Niche Creator Performance Auditor